How to get the most out of topology optimization

With the rise of additive manufacturing and introduction of limitless complexity, read this blog to learn how to utilize topology optimization to its fullest potential.

Andrew Sartorelli
March 19, 2020 • 4 min read

With a name like nTopology, people often assume that we only do topology optimization. And while that isn’t quite true (have you seen our implicit modeling?), we are doing some incredible things to remove the hassle from topology optimization-driven workflows. While the engineering and mathematics behind this optimization process have been around for decades, with the rise of industrial additive manufacturing and the limitless complexity that it enables, we’ve seen the exponential growth in the utilization of topology optimization. But with that growth in usage comes an ever-increasing understanding of the frustrating limitations that occur when traditional design techniques are combined with topology optimization. However, next-generation design tools like nTop Platform can help ease away those limitations to enable engineers to create better performing parts, faster.

What is Topology Optimization?

Topology optimization is a numerical optimization method that optimizes the placement of material inside a user-defined design space. By providing boundary conditions and constraints, objectives such as maximizing the stiffness of a component can be obtained. This method has seen a significant increase in adoption with the advances in computing power accessible to every engineer and the industrialization of additive manufacturing. In a general sense, topology optimization iterates through and removes the unnecessary material to identify the most optimal load path.

Bracket design space and unmodified topology optimization result.

nTop Platform currently uses a density-based approach to topology optimization. After applying loads, constraints, and optimization objectives, one ends up with an element density field, which can vary between 0, indicating no material, and 1 indicating solid material. The user is then able to determine a threshold between those values to generate their component. While many tools, including nTop Platform, have stress constraints for topology optimization, there is still the need to validate the part afterward. Which may result in needing to change the density threshold.

Using topology optimization as a design tool often makes a lot of sense, as it is able to lightweight a design in a manner an engineer could never do manually, by precisely conserving materials along load paths. However, now that the design exploration phase is complete,  many users will start to run into major pain points such as the output of the topology optimization process not immediately being able to be manufactured, validated, or incorporated back into existing design workflows. These problems all stem from the fact that the density field is applied to discrete elements and not to a continuous object, which results in a jagged and unappetizing triangle soup.

Several steps can be taken to push the result to a form that can be validated, manufactured, or incorporated into further design processes. With traditional design tools, the process to get there tends to be tedious and littered with limitations, which often falsely sets engineers’ expectations of what is possible with topology optimization.

How nTop Platform Solves These Pain Points

Traditional Geometry Reconstruction

With traditional tools, one often ends up applying mesh based smoothing but ends up losing the functional faces that are so important for manufacturing and further design process. Or one ends up stuck with a problematic mesh that contains holes, overlapping triangles, and an array of other issues. Some traditional tools have an entirely manual process requiring users to tediously use sketch-based modeling tools to remodel the result of their topology optimization. While one can end up with some great geometry as a result of this manual process, if you adjust the threshold to add slightly more material, you end up redoing all of your modeling operations!

Next Gen Geometry Reconstruction

In a robust modeling software like nTop Platform, you can quickly apply smoothing techniques to end up with clean, organic geometry, no more worrying about mesh problems or manual reconstruction here. Afterward, simply add back functional regions with volumetric boolean operations that never fail. Best of all, if you decide to update your density threshold all the operations will replay, no need to worry about manually redoing any work. 

Traditional Post-Optimization Validation

When performing validation of a topology optimized part, users can be left with geometry that is missing the associativity to the applied loads and constraints from the optimization. This requires the user to go set up loads and boundary conditions or perhaps even find entirely new ways to apply them if it was done on a mesh basis. Which may not be easy to do, because there is no longer the same set of functional geometry.

Next Gen Post-Optimization Validation

Loads and boundary conditions can effortlessly be carried over from topology optimization to be used for validation of resultant geometry inside nTop Platform. The same loads and constraints can even be used when sending geometry to 3rd party validation tools like Ansys Mechanical, Abaqus, Nastran, LS-DYNA, and more.

Traditional Path to Manufacturing

After painstakingly converting your topology optimization result into a surface mesh, you often spend additional time applying mesh repair to finally end up with data that’s usable in your manufacturing process. 

Next Gen Path to Manufacturing

Users can directly slice (for select additive manufacturing machines) their finished functional part after automatically reconstructing geometry. Eliminating the inefficient step of generating a mesh which is then sliced in build prep software. 

Want to Dig Deeper?

One of the more popular uses of topology optimization is reducing the mass of a part while ensuring structural integrity. If you’re curious how nTopology approaches a start-to-finish topology optimization process, then check out this how-to video. We’ll illustrate our approach, in addition to providing answers to some of those considerations and challenges — such as how our implicit modeling technology enables you to automatically reconstruct usable geometry directly from topology optimization results.

Written by
Product Manager
Andrew Sartorelli graduated from the University of New Hampshire with a Bachelor’s of Science in Mechanical Engineering. Joining Autodesk in 2013, initially as post-sales application engineer for their line of structural analysis products. In 2017, he transitioned into a role as a Technical Project Manager and Product Owner at Autodesk GmbH, focusing on additive manufacturing. In 2019, he joined nTopology GmbH as a Senior Application Engineer for the European market, and most recently became Product Manager for nTop Platform.

Up Next

nTop and ORNL collaborating to develop innovative toolkits

Along with ORNL we are going to develop a number of new toolkits with the intent of connecting design and additive manufacturing processes. We will ultimately make these toolkits available to all nTop Platform users.

Duann Scott
nTopology and COVID-19

We are here to help

Bradley Rothenberg